Is the quality of traffic different today for local businesses?

Up Next:

• Part 1How Local SEO is Evolving in AI Discovery

  Local pack ads grew from 1% to 22% of tracked searches. Joy Hawkins, owner and president of Sterling Sky, has led over 1,000 local SEO tests across nearly two decades to determine which ranking factors actually drive results for local businesses. This conversation covers why algorithmic domain-wide penalties are now hitting small businesses that scale AI-generated location and model pages, how authority signals for local have shifted toward Google reviews, active social presence, indexed Facebook groups, and third-party awards rather than link building, and why call tracking with recorded calls and integrated texting outperforms traffic metrics for measuring genuine lead quality.

  Play Podcast
• Part 2What data should businesses really be showing on their website?

  Local pack ads jumped from 1% to 22% of tracked searches. Joy Hawkins, owner and president of Sterling Sky, brings nearly two decades of local search expertise and over 1,000 documented ranking tests to explain what actually moves the needle as AI reshapes local visibility. The conversation covers non-link authority signals—social UGC, active YouTube channels, Google reviews, and industry awards—that now feed AI-powered local packs, the escalating penalty risk from scaled content and link building following recent core updates, and lead qualification frameworks built on call tracking, response-time automation, and integrated texting to separate real revenue from vanity metrics.

  Play Podcast
• Current Podcast

  Part 3Is the quality of traffic different today for local businesses?

  Local pack ads grew from 1% to 22% of tracked searches. Joy Hawkins, owner and president of Sterling Sky, brings nearly two decades studying local results and over 1,000 local SEO tests to explain why traffic and lead quality no longer move together. The conversation covers redefining lead qualification through call tracking and duration thresholds, the growing penalty risk of scaled content and link building for small businesses, and building authority through reviews, awards, and social signals rather than links. Hawkins also makes the data-backed case for YouTube over LLM optimization and the physical location requirements behind local pack visibility.